Astrology memes, angel numbers on your feed, tarot cards at the coffee shop, crystals in your pocket — what used to be niche is now everywhere. TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube have turned spiritual practices into trends, blending entertainment with promises of healing, clarity, and love.

At first, it feels lighthearted. But for many of my clients, getting deeply involved in these practices has led to confusion, obsession, and feeling stuck in life.

Why Magical Thinking Is So Appealing

People are drawn to astrology, crystals, tarot, and fortune telling for real reasons:

• Identity. “I’m a Virgo, so I must be perfectionistic.”
• Community. “We Scorpios just understand each other.”
• Comfort in uncertainty. “Mercury retrograde explains why everything is going wrong.”
• Hope. “The right card, spell, or number will finally bring me love or success.”

These tools can feel validating. But when they shift from entertainment to life compass, problems emerge.

How These Practices Began — and Why They Took Over

Many of the spiritual practices that are trendy today actually have deep historical roots:

• Astrology. Originating in Babylon over 2,000 years ago, astrology was used to track seasons, predict harvests, and guide leaders. Over time, horoscopes shifted into personalized identity systems.
• Crystals. Ancient Egyptians, Greeks, and Chinese cultures used crystals in rituals, burials, and medicine for protection or healing.
• Tarot and fortune telling. Tarot cards began in 15th-century Europe as a card game before evolving into divination tools. Fortune telling has existed across cultures as a way to explain uncertainty when scientific answers weren’t available.
• Witchcraft and spells. Folk healers and shamans used rituals, herbs, and charms as early medicine and spiritual protection.
• Angel numbers. Rooted in numerology, these mystical interpretations of numbers appeared in early spiritual traditions but spread globally only with the internet.

Originally, these practices were ways for cultures to cope with uncertainty and make sense of the unknown. What’s different today is how social media has amplified them into everyday life:

• Relatable astrology memes spread faster than mental health education.
• Tarot and fortune telling accounts frame card pulls as life guidance.
• Angel number posts encourage constant sign-seeking (“If you saw 11:11 today, your soulmate is near”).
• Crystal shops and spell kits are marketed as self-care must-haves.
• Manifestation influencers sell expensive programs promising quick fixes for heartbreak, success, or money.

What began as ancient meaning-making has become a global industry — designed less for wisdom, and more for clicks, followers, and sales.

The Hidden Costs of Magical Thinking

For many clients I’ve worked with, immersion in astrology, tarot, or witchcraft has caused:

• Obsessive patterns. Needing to pull cards daily, search for angel numbers, or check horoscopes before making decisions.
• Strained relationships. Using tarot or astrology as “proof” in fights, or excusing toxic relationships because of “twin flame” labels.
• Financial strain. Spending heavily on crystals, spells, or fortune tellers without meaningful results.
• Emotional suffering. Feeling miserable, anxious, or hopeless when the cards or numbers didn’t predict what they hoped.

Instead of creating clarity, these practices often leave people more confused and disconnected from reality.

Magical Thinking vs. Evidence-Based Healing

Here’s the critical difference:

• Affirmations. Reshape negative thought patterns through cognitive-behavioral science (Tod et al., 2011).
• Meditation. Shown to reduce stress, improve focus, and regulate emotion (Goyal et al., 2014).
• Mindfulness. Builds resilience and reduces rumination (Keng et al., 2011).
• Magical thinking. Outsources control to planets, tarot spreads, or rituals. Research links it to anxiety and impaired problem-solving (Subbotsky, 2004; Lillqvist & Lindeman, 1998).

Affirmations and mindfulness strengthen self-agency. Magical practices, when taken too far, weaken it.

Faith vs. Magical Practices

For clients from religious backgrounds, these trends often create tension. Christianity and Islam emphasize prayer, scripture, and accountability — practices that research shows support resilience and well-being (Koenig, 2012).

Magical frameworks like tarot, angel numbers, or witchcraft, however, can create instability because the “rules” keep shifting. Instead of fostering peace, they often fuel dependency and obsession.

Red Flags of Magical Thinking

Here are some signs that astrology, crystals, tarot, or spiritual practices may be crossing from curiosity into harmful territory:

• Constant sign-seeking. Needing tarot cards, angel numbers, or horoscopes before making decisions.
• Blame-shifting. Explaining away mistakes or conflicts with “Mercury retrograde” instead of accountability.
• Financial drain. Spending excessive amounts on crystals, fortune tellers, or spells without lasting change.
• Relationship strain. Using readings in arguments or staying in toxic relationships because of “twin flame” labels.
• Increased anxiety. Feeling panicked if you miss a ritual, card pull, or number.
• Isolation. Pulling away from friends or family who don’t share the same beliefs.
• Difficulty moving forward. Remaining stagnant while waiting for signs instead of taking action.

Green Flags of Healthy Spirituality

Not all spiritual or reflective practices are harmful. Here are signs that your approach is helping you grow instead of keeping you stuck:

• Grounded practices. Prayer, mindfulness, journaling, or meditation that bring calm without fear if you skip a day.
• Encourages accountability. Inspires you to own your choices rather than blaming signs or cards.
• Supports relationships. Builds compassion and understanding instead of fueling judgment.
• Flexible and balanced. Enriches your life without dictating every decision.
• Evidence-informed. Incorporates affirmations, therapy, or mindfulness tools supported by research.
• Hopeful, not fearful. Leaves you feeling peaceful and empowered — not guilty or stuck.

Why So Many Get Stuck

Clients I’ve worked with who immersed themselves in astrology, tarot, or witchcraft often share the same outcomes:

• Feeling miserable and anxious.
• Obsessive checking of cards or signs.
• Difficulty making decisions without external validation.
• Staying in toxic relationships reframed as “divine.”

Despite the promises of empowerment, these practices often keep people circling the same struggles — stuck instead of moving forward.

Closing Thought

Astrology, tarot, and angel numbers may feel fun or comforting. But when they shift from entertainment to guidance, they often fuel obsession, suffering, and stagnation.

Healing doesn’t come from fortune tellers or card spreads — it comes from building self-trust, setting boundaries, and leaning on practices grounded in evidence or faith.

At Crescent Counseling & Coaching, I help clients break free from cycles of magical thinking and create lasting growth through therapy, mindfulness, and solution-focused strategies.

______

References

• Dean, G., Mather, A., & Kelly, I. (2003). Astrology and human judgment. Psychological Reports, 93(3), 931–935.
• French, C. C., & Stone, A. (2014). Anomalistic psychology: Exploring paranormal belief and experience.Palgrave Macmillan.
• Goyal, M., et al. (2014). Meditation programs for psychological stress and well-being: A systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Internal Medicine, 174(3), 357–368.
• Keng, S. L., Smoski, M. J., & Robins, C. J. (2011). Effects of mindfulness on psychological health: A review of empirical studies. Clinical Psychology Review, 31(6), 1041–1056.
• Koenig, H. G. (2012). Religion, spirituality, and health: The research and clinical implications. ISRN Psychiatry, 2012, 278730.
• Lillqvist, O., & Lindeman, M. (1998). Belief in astrology as a strategy for coping with personal uncertainty. European Psychologist, 3(3), 202–208.
• Subbotsky, E. (2004). Magical thinking in judgments of causation. British Journal of Developmental Psychology, 22(1), 123–152.
• Tod, D., Hardy, J., & Oliver, E. (2011). Effects of self-talk: A systematic review. Sport Psychologist, 25(1), 36–51.